Every footballer to have played for both Liverpool and Everton
By Mitch Wilks
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7e4c3/7e4c3962501346cbcc71e1e04212728cafff7321" alt="Peter Beardsley moved from Liverpool to Everton Peter Beardsley moved from Liverpool to Everton"
With just a 20 minute or so walk separating Anfield from Goodison Park, it's a wonder that not every Merseyside based player switches between the two clubs more frequently.
What, is there some sort of rivalry in the way or something?
While not always the closest on the pitch, the rivalry between Liverpool and Everton is intense and fierce, and always will be with the two grounds situated so close to one another, and the clubs meaning so much to the locals. The following players have turned out for both sides, and happen to be a list of particularly brave individuals.
35. Edgar Chadwick (Everton 1888-89, Liverpool 1902-04)
On this day in 1869, #EFC legend Edgar Chadwick was born.
— EFC Statto (@EFC_Statto) June 14, 2019
300 appearances
104 goals
1890/91 Football League champion
1 of only 9 Everton players to score 100+ goals
Played in Everton's first ever Football League match
2nd Everton player to score a goal for England pic.twitter.com/4k0EeogL2a
A period well before the modern game, Chadwick was an Everton hero in its earliest form.
11 years with the Toffees saw him build up an esteemed reputation as one of the game's finest attackers and won the top flight with them in 1891. A move to Liverpool in 1902 was a rather quiet two year spell after transferring from Burnley.
34. Andrew Hannah (Everton 1889-91, Liverpool 1892-95)
? | @EvertonHeritage, in conjunction with #EFC, have laid a headstone at the grave of the captain of our first league title-winning side.
— Everton (@Everton) March 26, 2018
Andrew Hannah (1864-1940)
?? https://t.co/8kkgtiGcZ2 pic.twitter.com/Yytt9c3Pz5
After initially moving down to England with West Brom but failing to settle, Scottish right back Hannah tried again with Everton in 1899.
He was ever-present in the Everton side that finished runners up in 1890 and impressed again as they went one better a year later, captaining the side as they won the league. He moved to Liverpool in 1892 after a brief third stint back in Scotland, with the new Merseyside club luring him in for three seasons.
33. Thomas G. Wylie (Everton 1890-92, Liverpool 1892-93)
Youngest Everton hat-trick scorers - #7 Tom Wylie v Derby 1890 (6-2) pic.twitter.com/iZMpGBKfjg
— Everton Records (@EvertonRecords) March 18, 2014
Scottish forward Wylie developed a habit of scoring goals at a regional level.
After success with Everton, Wylie moved to new club Liverpool and would feature regularly for them as they climbed up the divisions.
32. Duncan McLean (Everton 1890-92, Liverpool 1892-95)
Another Scot venturing down into the North of England, McLean was picked up by Everton and grew into the side after playing a bit part role in his debut season.
He was another who stayed at Anfield and turned out for newly formed Liverpool in 1892 following Everton's walk away from the ground.
31. Patrick Gordon (Everton 1890-93, Liverpool 1893-94)
Born #OTD 150 yrs ago. Patrick Gordon who won the League title at Anfield for both Everton(1890-91) and Liverpool (Div 2, 1893-94) pic.twitter.com/NsoUWZxyLz
— London Toffees (@ESCLA1975) February 19, 2020
While plenty stayed at Anfield and signed for Liverpool straight away, Patrick Gordon moved with Everton for another season before moving to the Reds.
Gordon was a part of the Liverpool side that won its first title.
30. John Whitehead (Everton 1893, Liverpool 1894-95)
A local lad that started with Bootle, Whitehead only spent a year with Everton before signing on to play for Liverpool.
Little else is known about the goalkeeper's career.
29. Fred Geary (Everton 1889-95, Liverpool 1895-96)
? | After @Everton were disallowed a legitimate goal against Accrington Stanley that cost them victory in an important match, an Evertonian invented the goal net.
— Everton in the USA (@EvertonInUSA) January 14, 2019
Evertonian, Fred Geary was legally the 1st player to ever hit the back of the net.
➡️ https://t.co/A0Qz4bpW59#EFC pic.twitter.com/cBkFFqmzNg
A centre forward with no hesitation over scoring goals, Geary was playing for Everton and later Liverpool when not scoring hat-tricks on his England debut.
Geary was integral up top as Everton won the First Division in 1891 and is deemed by supporters as the first real icon they had; the Dixie Dean before he came to be.
28. Alex Latta (Everton 1889-95, Liverpool 1895-96)
On this day in 1894, Everton beat Liverpool 3-0 in the first ever Merseyside Derby. Tom McInnes, Alex Latta and Jack Bell scored for the Blues. #EFC pic.twitter.com/q1ecZxTPQx
— EFC Statto (@EFC_Statto) October 13, 2018
Another talent brought down from Scotland, Latta was the outside right forward deployed as Everton won the league in 1891.
His career wrapped up with the new crosstown rivals, spending a year with Liverpool before his retirement.
27. Abe Hartley (Everton 1892-97, Liverpool 1904-05)
Starting out in Dumbarton, Hartley really got around the Football League in the early 20th century.
Aside from spells with Everton - where he was a runner up in the 1987 FA Cup - and Liverpool, Hartley also turned out for Southampton, Arsenal and Burnley. A journeyman ahead of his time.
26. David Murray (Everton 1903-04, Liverpool 1904-05)
OTD in 1915, former Leeds City captain David Murray was killed at Hulluch, near Loos, while serving with the Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders. The ex Rangers, Everton & Liverpool full-back made 83 appearances for Leeds City (1905 - 1909). He is remembered on the Loos Memorial. pic.twitter.com/E5P3gQGjxA
— History of Leeds (@rh0desy) December 10, 2018
Moving down from Scotland, Murray only turned out twice in the league for Everton before moving onto Liverpool in 1904.
He won back-to-back Second Division and First Division titles with the club - despite not featuring all that much in the second season - but was tragically killed when serving in the First World War in 1915.
25. Billy Scott (Everton 1904-12, Liverpool 1912-14)
Everton goalkeeper Billy Scott who recommended his brother Elisha to Liverpool pic.twitter.com/szVrG6gWU0
— The League Magazine (@Theleaguemag) June 9, 2014
One half of an Irish goalkeeping brothers duo, Scott enjoyed a storied career with Everton and represented them in 251 league outings, before moving on in 1912.
He spent two years with Liverpool, whom he encouraged to sign his younger brother Elisha; perhaps his best contribution to the club.
24. Arthur Berry (Liverpool 1906-09, 1912, Everton 1910-11)
Great Britain won the 1912 Olympic football with a team of amateurs who were playing at professional clubs. The First World War impacted their lives and careers. Half of the lineup entered the army and served all over the world. pic.twitter.com/sQvAYoqvvy
— Football Makes History (@MakesFootball) March 30, 2020
Not only did Berry represent both Liverpool and Everton and shift the tide in terms of players beginning with Liverpool, but his excellence went beyond league football.
He represented Great Britain at the 1908 and 1912 Olympics, winning gold at both events, before retiring in 1914 to become a barrister.
23. Don Sloan (Everton 1906-08, Liverpool 1908-09)
Scottish goalkeeper Sloan moved to Everton in 1906 after impressing in the Scottish and Irish leagues.
Two years with Everton and a year with Liverpool was his football career high, before moving back to Distillery and eventually serving in the war. He was killed in 1917.
22. Harold Uren (Liverpool 1906-12, Everton 1912-13)
Harold Uren - 24 apps, 3 goals pic.twitter.com/Qsx0u69kQT
— Everton Records (@EvertonRecords) October 24, 2013
A speedy winger by trade, Uren signed on amateur terms with Liverpool in 1906 before slowly working his way into the first team and becoming a regular.
Liverpool sold him to Everton in 1913 for £300 and two players; Tom Gracie and Bill Lacey.
21. Bill Lacey (Everton 1909-12, Liverpool 1912-15, 1919-24)
Two clubs: Bill Lacey of Liverpool and Everton pic.twitter.com/dO7OlIDK
— The League Magazine (@Theleaguemag) January 8, 2013
Rising to prominence in Ireland for his commendable versatility on the pitch, Everton signed Lacey in 1909 but was quickly snapped up by Liverpool in the exchange deal.
Lacey enjoyed a fine career with the Reds and made hundreds of appearances before and after the war, returning to Ireland in between for guest appearances.
20. Tom Gracie (Everton 1911-12, Liverpool 1912-14)
Former Everton, Liverpool and Heart of Midlothian player Tom Gracie, who was part of the @JamTarts side that joined McCrae's Battalion en-masse in November 1914, died from leukaemia on this day in 1915. #ww1 #worldwar1 #Everton #LiverpoolFC #EFC #LFC #hearts @Everton @LFC pic.twitter.com/ysebU0Cb5r
— Football & the First World War (@FootballWW1) October 23, 2018
While the swap deal proved fruitful for Lacey, moving to Liverpool didn't bare the same fortunes for Gracie.
Picked up by Everton by making the Scotland squad for a friendly against England, he was included in the swap but moved back to Scotland in 1914. He balanced a rich vein of form with serving in the war, but died of leukaemia in 1915.
19. Frank Mitchell (Everton 1913-15, 1919-20, Liverpool 1921)
Mitchell moved down from Scotland to sign for Everton and stuck with them throughout the war, but never became the established number one goalkeeper at any point.
He moved across town to Liverpool in 1921 but again couldn't get in regularly over the highly thought of Elisha Scott.
18. Benjamin Howard Baker (Liverpool 1919-20, Everton 1921)
He played for Everton, Chelsea, Preston, Corinthian, England and England amateurs. He was in two Olympics in the high jump.
— The League Magazine (@Theleaguemag) December 5, 2018
He was also good at Tennis, Water Polo and Cricket.
And he impressed Lily Langtry!
Read about Benjamin Howard Baker herehttps://t.co/c3SBrPEiMS pic.twitter.com/V6Vptbx4ao
Not unusual for the time, but completely baffling to look back on, Baker was more than a footballer. Like, so much more.
Baker competed for Great Britain in high jump events at the Olympics, while also competing regularly in long jump, hurdles and tennis. In football, he started outfield, but became a goalkeeper following an injury in World War One. After playing just about every sport fathomable, he retired and went into business.
17. Dick Forshaw (Liverpool 1919-27, Everton 1927-29)
Double league winner with Liverpool, Dick Forshaw scored 123 goals in 288 matches for the Reds before a controversial move on 2 March 1927 to Everton where he won the championship in his first full season. Forshaw was in and out of jail for most of the 1930s for theft and fraud. pic.twitter.com/EfImiv4k4F
— LFChistory.net (@LFChistory) March 2, 2021
Forshaw remains the only player in history to have won league titles with both Liverpool and Everton.
He signed professional terms with Liverpool in 1919 and enjoyed a fine stint as a regular goal getter. He moved to Everton in 1927 and helped them along to a First Division win, too.
16. Neil McBain (Everton 1923-26, Liverpool 1928)
At 51 years old, McBain remains the oldest player to turn out in the English Football League. Don't expect that to change anytime soon.
After serving in World War One, he got a break in England with Manchester United, before moving to Everton in 1923. After returning to Scotland, a 1928 move to Liverpool was unfortunately short lived.
15. Tommy Johnson (Everton 1930-34, Liverpool 1934-36)
Everton duo Dixie Dean and Tommy Johnson back in 1931#EFC #Everton pic.twitter.com/1CoGzzb60x
— Football Memories (@footballmemorys) March 27, 2016
While rivalries were still nowhere near as fierce as they are now, football becoming more popular meant switching between rival sides would become gradually less frequent.
Johnson - an electric forward who ripped it up for Manchester City - moved to Everton and played alongside the legendary Dixie Dean. Always overshadowed, a move to Liverpool in 1934 helped them avoid relegation.
14. Jack Balmer (Everton 1934-35, Liverpool 1935-52)
After being released by Everton at the end of the season, Jack Balmer signed for Liverpool FC on 15 May 1935. Balmer was 19 when he joined #LFC.
— LFChistory.net (@LFChistory) May 15, 2021
110 goals in all official competitions and a 1st Division winners' medal is a decent outcome as for a free transfer!#LFChistory_net pic.twitter.com/IrWBvTB6Mx
A local lad from West Derby, Balmer was signed to Everton on amateur terms, but was poached by Liverpool as a teenager in 1935.
Balmer was a prodigy before the Second World War, and played again for Liverpool afterwards as a more well rounded striker. 111 goals came from his 312 appearances.
13. Billy Harthill (Everton 1935, Liverpool 1936)
Harthill was given the name 'Artillery' for his service as a bombardier after leaving school. It does not get cooler than that.
While he turned out for both Merseyside clubs, he had little fortune with either of them. Instead, Harthill's career high was his spell with Wolves before moving to Everton.
12. John Heydon (Everton 1946-49, Liverpool 1949-53)
Heydon spent three years honing his craft in Everton's reserve setup as a teenager, before being signed by Liverpool aged 20 in 1949.
It took him a short while to break in, but Heydon then enjoyed a run as a regular before moving on again in 1953.
11. Tony McNamara (Everton 1947-57, Liverpool 1957-58)
It’s with great sadness that we’ve learned of the passing of ex-Everton player Tony McNamara. http://t.co/dttoX4pWxd pic.twitter.com/UfJFFOeFnY
— Everton (@Everton) May 30, 2015
Officially beyond the Second World War, football began to stride into a new wave of popularity and prowess.
McNamara's decade long stint with Everton was a commendable feat and the best years of his career. While his venture across Stanley Park was short, it lead to him becoming the only player to play in all four English divisions within 12 months. He passed away in 2015.
10. Jimmy Payne (Liverpool 1948-56, Everton 1956-57)
Four weeks after making his debut, Jimmy Payne scored the first of his 43 #LFC goals on 9 October 1948. Liverpool played against Chelsea at Anfield and were 1-0 down, but Payne got a late equaliser and the game finished in a 1-1 draw.#LFChistory_net pic.twitter.com/yGLOSnJPpJ
— LFChistory.net (@LFChistory) October 9, 2020
Growing up an Everton fan wasn't enough to stop Payne signing terms with Liverpool as an 18-year-old.
It proved the right decision. Payne became a regular fixture for the Reds as a tricky winger, but could only come away with the honour of being runners up in the 1950 FA Cup before moving to Everton for a season.
9. Dave Hickson (Everton 1948-55, 1957-59, Liverpool 1959-61)
Dave Hickson simply just couldn't get enough of the Ev.
Signing in 1948 but not debuting for three years due to national service, Hickson flew for the Toffees. An aggressive and physical striker, he bagged goals for fun as the target man, but his 1959 move to Liverpool wasn't a popular one among fans. We're heading into the rock 'n roll years, remember?
8. Johnny Morrissey (Liverpool 1957-62, Everton 1962-72)
Coming up through the Liverpool academy from a young age, failure to nail down a spot saw Morrissey head across Stanley Park to join Everton in 1962.
He scored in the first Merseyside derby for 11 seasons and fired Everton to a First Division title in his maiden season. That electric start turned into a decade of service for the Toffees, before finishing up with Oldham Athletic.
7. David Johnson (Everton 1969-72, 1982-84, Liverpool 1976-82)
Switching between the two sides was now becoming less frequent with the history built and the rivalries growing more passionate.
Liverpool had an eye on Johnson from young, but despite Bill Shankly's best efforts, they couldn't stop him debuting with the Toffees. He eventually arrived via Ipswich as a seasoned striker and racked up a fine cabinet of domestic and European honours, before returning to the Toffees later on.
6. Kevin Sheedy (Liverpool 1978-82, Everton 1982-92)
Capped 46 times by the Republic of Ireland and scoring their first ever goal at a World Cup finals, Sheedy had a tough start in Liverpool.
He barely featured in a four year spell and was allowed to leave for Everton, where the midfielder found his feet. Sheedy was integral in Everton's last true golden era, picking up two league titles and a European Cup Winners' Cup.
5. Steve McMahon (Everton 1979-83, Liverpool 1983-91)
Strolling around and bossing midfields in those endlessly short shorts of the 80s, Steve McMahon's best stuff came with the Reds.
Despite being at Everton from as early as ball-boy level, he found his way to Liverpool where he was key in winning three league titles and two FA Cups.
4. Peter Beardsley (Liverpool 1987-91, Everton 1991-93)
For a man who set a record transfer fee in 1987, Beardsley's journeyman-like career has taken him everywhere.
From Canada to Newcastle, Beardsley was electric for Liverpool in their final few years of success before the Premier League era. They sold him aged 30 to rivals Everton in 1991, where his impact was rather muted.
3. Gary Ablett (Liverpool 1985-92, Everton 1992-96)
Seven years with Liverpool and a hoarding of trophies included defender Ablett winning the 1989 FA Cup against Everton.
That wasn't enough, though, and following his transfer, Ablett won the FA Cup with the Toffees upon his arrival, making him the only player to date to have won the cup with both teams. He passed away in 2012 following a battle with non-Hodgkin Lymphoma.
2. Nick Barmby (Everton 1996-00, Liverpool 2000-02)
Your dad's favourite attacking midfielder, Barmby enjoyed a fine four years at Everton as a big fish in what had become a rather small pond.
Barmby excelled for the mid-table outfit, so much so that it forced the Toffees into selling a player to Liverpool for the first time since Dave Hickson's move in 1959.
1. Abel Xavier (Everton 1999-02, Liverpool 2002-03)
After moving around Europe to moderate degrees of success, Everton snapped up Xavier for a £1.5m fee in 1999.
The defender impressed and controversially made the move across the park for a lesser transfer fee in 2002 after eyeing improved terms with his contract running down. His move to the Reds didn't work, however, and he was gone by 2003.