X reacts as VAR controversy dominates Liverpool win over Crystal Palace
- VAR took centre stage during Liverpool's win over Crystal Palace
- Referee Andy Madley awarded the Eagles a controversial penalty in the second half
- Jordan Ayew sent off before the game turned in Liverpool's favour

Referee Andy Madley and VAR took centre stage during Liverpool's 2-1 win over Crystal Palace at Selhurst Park, with controversial penalty and red card decisions sure to dominate the evening's headlines.
Liverpool managed to win the game thanks to another late turnaround, Mohamed Salah and Harvey Elliott's strikes overturning a one-goal deficit.
However, it was inevitably the officials under the spotlight, with the ongoing debate of what constitutes a clear and obvious error raging in the crowd, on the commentary gantry and, most importantly, on social media.
Before all the chaos unfolded, there was good news for Liverpool prior to kick-off as Alisson was welcomed back in goal for the Reds. The Brazilian had been missing after sustaining a muscle strain against Manchester City in late November, but his comeback was greeted with plenty of positivity.
A welcome sight for Liverpool fans with Alisson back between the sticks for them against Crystal Palace. π§€ pic.twitter.com/HxvMswH6ol
β 90min (@90min_Football) December 9, 2023
Alisson being back so early is killing me, Klopp is shook with Kelleher
β π₯·πΏ (@Bk8iP3) December 9, 2023
And Liverpool's shot-stopper proved his worth just before the 30-minute mark, producing a truly astonishing save to keep out Jefferson Lerma's close-range effort. Jurgen Klopp will certainly be pleased to have the 31-year-old back...
Alisson Becker is the greatest goalkeeper I have ever seen.
β Samuel (@SamueILFC) December 9, 2023
Save of the season!!! Alisson is unbelievable!!!
β Mark Goldbridge (@markgoldbridge) December 9, 2023
Alisson every single week pic.twitter.com/hDBfse7OL1
β Out of Context Football Manager (@nocontextfm1) December 9, 2023
Just moments after Alisson's wonder save, Crystal Palace were awarded a penalty when Virgil van Dijk felled Odsonne Edouard in the area.
However, there was a pretty clear foul, to many but not all, on Wataru Endo in the build-up to the decision, with referee Madley eventually reversing the call after a lengthy delay and VAR check.
It did NOT need that long to decide that it was NOT a penalty, Jesus man why do they need so long πππππ
β Liam π« (@LiamMLFC) December 9, 2023
Thatβs a foul on Endo by Hughes. Wraps his right leg around him and tugs the shirt. Given LFC are a title rival, Iβd much rather see the penalty given but we canβt keep bleating on about poor decisions & ignoring the ones that suit us.
β Harry Symeou (@HarrySymeou) December 9, 2023
Amazing how many times he has to look at it while he tries to find a way to allow the penalty.
β Jimmy Ho-Ho-Hell (@SeeingRedv2) December 9, 2023
Just make the sport non-contact
β Scott Saunders (@__scottsaunders) December 9, 2023
Not clear and obvious, total ruination of the sport. For no reason
β Buvey (@lawrence_bury) December 9, 2023
Despite the VAR drama, the game would enter half-time goalless, with Liverpool more than a little ponderous in the opening 45 minutes.
Knowing a win would take them top, the Reds needed to step it up at Selhurst Park...
No penalty. Liverpool need to improve here.
β - (@JoshLFC1909) December 9, 2023
Come on Liverpool weβre better than this.
β Wozza * (@redwozza) December 9, 2023
Crystal Palace may have been denied a penalty in the first half, but they were gifted a rather remarkable one early in the second.
Despite the game having continued for 105 seconds after Jarell Quansah's challenge on Jean-Philippe Mateta in the box, Madley was eventually asked by VAR to take a look at the decision, stopping the game mid-flow before awarding the spot-kick to the Eagles.
A truly bizarre situation that is seldom seen in the Premier League.
So you can stop play and go back two minutes to award a penalty but you canβt stop the game to give an actual goal thatβs already been given by the VAR. Great.
β Joel Rabinowitz (@joel_archie) December 9, 2023
Ridiculous penalty decision. #CRYLIV
β JosΓ© Mourinho (@josemourinhotv) December 9, 2023
On the one hand, if it takes VAR that long, itβs not a clear and obvious error. On the other hand, itβs the most obvious penalty of all time. #CRYLIV
β Frankie Boyle Updates (@frankieboyle) December 9, 2023
Game resumed and called back for a penalty several minutes later yet against Spurs they couldn't call it back for a goal for Liverpool. Make sense of that.
β Bernard (@bernardpj) December 9, 2023
But Madley wasn't done with his whistle just yet, sending off Jordan Ayew for a second yellow card after a fairly tame challenge on Elliott. Unsurprisingly, the decision sparked debate.
Just seen the replay of the Ayew second yellow thatβs frankly a hilarious call Iβm not even entirely sure itβs a foul
β πΎ (@dreezabz) December 9, 2023
A bizarre one for Crystal Palace π«’
β Football on TNT Sports (@footballontnt) December 9, 2023
Was Jordan Ayew's red card fair? π¬π₯ pic.twitter.com/917MNiqiaT
Not sure what the controversy is over Ayew one. The first yellow he was being a dick and delaying the restart, the second one was a foul that stopped the opposition from breaking, rightly or wrongly those fouls have been getting yellow cards all season
β Ste Davies (@StevenD1977) December 9, 2023
Just minutes after Ayew's dismissal, Liverpool took advantage, Salah's deflected effort levelling proceedings. A pretty significant way to score his 200th goal for the Reds and his 150th in the Premier League.
Mohamed Salah has grabbed his 150th Premier League goal! π΄π₯
β Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) December 9, 2023
The winger also becomes only the fifth player in Liverpool's history to reach 200 goals for the club! π pic.twitter.com/ORUYF3biLj
150 - Mohamed Salah has scored his 150th goal in the Premier League, while he's reached this tally in the fifth-fewest appearances of any player:
β OptaJoe (@OptaJoe) December 9, 2023
212 - Alan Shearer
217 - Sergio AgΓΌero
218 - Harry Kane
220 - Thierry Henry
247 - Mohamed Salah
Icon. pic.twitter.com/vLwNj30VWs
Despite Palace's best efforts to secure a hard-fought point at Selhurst Park, substitute Elliott unleashed a venomous strike from the edge of the area to give Liverpool a late lead.
Regardless of the controversial VAR calls, it was a goal worthy of winning any match.
PURE CLASS! β¨
β Football on TNT Sports (@footballontnt) December 9, 2023
Harvey Elliott scores a wonderful goal to put Liverpool ahead π₯
What a goal! π pic.twitter.com/s19ttdO9P9
The new super sub Harvey Elliott!
β Jamie Carragher (@Carra23) December 9, 2023
Every game he makes a difference from the bench.
Who sets up the winning goal for Elliott? Mo Salah. The master and the apprentice. π
β Samuel (@SamueILFC) December 9, 2023
However, it was ultimately the officials who were the major talking point from a breathless clash between Crystal Palace and Liverpool on Saturday.
Btw, Crystal Palace and Liverpool on the wrong side of officiating today. Some shocking decisions against both sides.
β π (@LFCApproved) December 9, 2023
As fans of this league we shouldnβt let it continue, referees are so incompetent.
Mikel is right. It canβt be the best league in the world if the referees are such a disgrace like this.
β π½ππππ πΉπππ (@rockynico) December 9, 2023
These referees are absolutely crazy. This sport is gone man.
β Moby (@Mobyhaque1) December 9, 2023
READ THE LATEST PREMIER LEAGUE NEWS, RUMOURS & GOSSIP
feed